Make Known Unknown (Blog 9)

Are State Schools Really the More Affordable Option?

Public state colleges and universities are generally known as more affordable options for in-state students, providing those from low income households a means to a higher education. After reading a ProPublica article about college debt, however, I learned that many public universities have been shifting their financial aid to wealthier students, leaving the poor behind. This is mostly due to the universities’ own economic shortcomings and desire to increase their institutional prestige and boost rankings.

It appears as if institutions are thinking more about their own self-interests rather than about their prospective students. Most of the financial aid is given is merit-based or given to athletes and international students, with very little need based aid being given. State schools would rather attract the smart students who can also pay, thereby decreasing their own financial burden. In addition to generating revenue, universities are also trying to attract the highest performing students whose scores will boost their rankings and prestige and allow them to keep up with private institutions.

Some colleges are arguing that this shift in aid is only short term and that the additional revenue generated will be given to more needy students in the future.  This may be somewhat true, but I am doubtful that this is the underling motivation. The shift of financial aid seems to be a strategic move to benefit their image.


There are clearly ethical implications involved in this issue. For example, the fact the public state schools are continuing to market themselves as affordable institutions that provide opportunities for all types of students is clearly misleading. Many students from low income families rely on state schools as a means to better their lives and receive a higher education, but clearly this is becoming much more difficult. I think that if public universities and colleges truly want to be successful they should focus more on the needs of their key stakeholders, prospective students and their families, rather than their own self interests.

6 thoughts on “Are State Schools Really the More Affordable Option?

  1. As someone who benefits from financial aid and is from the lower quartile of income, I find this horrifying. One thing I do know however which may be a factor in all of this is that private institutions actually can be less expensive and give more financial aid because they have larger endowments.

  2. Your post exposes the politics and inequalities of powerful institutions across the country. Those with privilege are disproportionately advantaged throughout their life, now even in higher education. I have always trusted institutions to grant scholarships to those who deserve it, apparently this is not the case.

  3. It is sad that institutions are implementing these policies. Instead of the institution providing the means for deserving students to attend their school, organizations have to take the lead. This is not right.

Leave a Reply to Jordi Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s